Which online publications are worth pitching, and how to tell
Not every article with a publication’s name on it does the same job. One placement gets forwarded to an investor and shows up when someone searches your name. Another sits on a page nobody visits and never gets read by anyone who matters to you.
Most of the difference is visible before you pitch. This is how we judge an online outlet, in the order we usually check things, so you can run the same test on any publication that comes up.
How do I evaluate a publication's target audience?
The first question is about the audience, and it has nothing to do with traffic numbers. Who opens this site on a Tuesday morning, and would you want them to know your name?
A fintech founder raising a round wants the people who read about funding, regulation and banking. A consumer brand wants shoppers and retail buyers. A cybersecurity company wants the CISOs and IT managers who sign off on tools. A huge general-interest site can look impressive and still miss all of them.
A simple way to check is to read five recent articles and look at who they are written for. Are the headlines about problems your buyers have? Do the comments, the author bios and the topics suggest a professional audience, or a casual one? If you cannot tell who the reader is, the outlet probably cannot tell either.
Then ask what you want the article to do. If a prospect will google you before replying to a cold email, you need coverage that looks credible on page one. If you are preparing for investor meetings, you need a name an investor recognizes. Different goals point to different outlets, and a good list usually mixes a few.
What is the difference between staff-written, contributed, and paid content?
Many large publications run several kinds of content under one logo, and they are not equal. It helps to know which one you are being offered.
Staff-written. A reporter or editor on the payroll chooses the story and writes it. This is the hardest to get and usually the strongest. You cannot buy it, and nobody should promise it to you.
Contributed. An outside expert writes a piece, and an editor reviews it and decides whether it runs. This is how many founders and executives appear in publications like Forbes, Entrepreneur or Inc. It is a normal and respected route, as long as an editor really is deciding what gets published.
Paid or sponsored. A company pays for a post, and the outlet publishes it with little or no editorial review. Good publications label these clearly. Readers notice the label, and so do search engines and AI assistants, so a sponsored post rarely carries the same weight as an edited article.
None of this means contributed work is second best. It means you should know what you are getting, and the outlet should be honest about it. If you cannot find out whether a section is edited, ask. A serious publication will have a clear answer.
How can I tell if an outlet is trusted by search and AI assistants?
You cannot see Google’s rankings from the outside, but you can see enough to make a sensible judgment. These are the things we look at.
Search the outlet’s name together with a topic you know well. If its articles regularly appear for that topic, search engines treat it as a source on the subject. Do the same for a competitor or a founder in your field and see which outlets show up beside their names.
Check how old articles are handled. Some publications keep every piece live and searchable for years. Others move older stories behind a paywall, archive them or let them disappear. A placement that is findable two years from now is worth more than one that is buried in a month.
Look at whether the outlet links out. A link from an article to your website helps your own search results, and it lets a reader click through to you. Not every good publication gives a followable link, so treat this as one point on the list and not a deal breaker.
Then test the AI assistants. Ask one a question your buyers would ask, such as which tools or experts to consider in your field, and see which publications it cites or draws on. Outlets that show up there are the ones the assistants already read. We cover this in more detail in how AI is changing PR.
Your own name is a useful test too. If you search for a founder in your industry who has been covered, the outlets on page one are telling you what works in your market.
Why should I pitch trade and regional publications?
A famous name is only one of the things worth checking. For many companies the better placement is a smaller outlet with exactly the right readers.
For B2B companies, the trade publication that buyers actually read often does more than a general business brand. A procurement lead or a head of IT may never open a national paper, but they read their industry site every week. We touch on this in five PR habits worth breaking.
Regional outlets work the same way. If you are entering a new market, a regional edition or a respected local business site can matter more than a global one, because it is what people in that market read and search. An edtech startup in Asia ran a story on e27 built around one student, and it gave the company a credible local reference that a global feature would not have.
For a solo consultant or a small firm, the logic is similar. A single profile in a recognized outlet, such as International Business Times Singapore, can become the first thing new clients ask about, because it is a clear sign that someone independent has vouched for the person. If that is your situation, our page on PR for small businesses and solopreneurs goes further.
The test is the same as before. Look at the readers, check how long the article stays findable, and see whether it fits the market you want to win.
What red flags should I look for when evaluating a publication?
Some warning signs are easy to spot once you know to look. Any one of them is a reason to slow down. Several together are a reason to walk away.
- The front page is full of sponsored posts. If most of what you see is promotional and unlabeled, the outlet is selling space and not running a newsroom.
- No editor is named. A real publication tells you who runs it. A masthead or an about page with named editors is a basic sign of accountability.
- Articles have no byline. If nobody puts a name on the work, nobody is answerable for it.
- The topics have nothing in common. A site that publishes casino reviews, crypto tips, dental advice and software news in the same week has no audience of its own.
- Everything is “published within 24 hours” for a fee. Real editors say no to some pitches. An outlet that never does is not much of a filter.
- The writing is thin or repetitive. Read a few pieces. If they are padded, full of errors or clearly produced in bulk, readers and search engines will treat them that way.
- Your article would sit next to content you would not want to be seen with. Context matters, because people will see the pages around yours.
A big name does not protect you from all of this. Some well-known sites have sections that are little more than paid directories, and some small sites are careful and well edited. Judge the section you would appear in, not only the logo above it.
What should I check before pitching a publication?
When an outlet is on the table, run through these questions. They take about ten minutes, and they save a lot of regret.
- Who reads it? Your buyers, your investors, your future hires, or none of them.
- Is the section edited? Know whether you are looking at staff work, an edited contributed piece or a paid post.
- Is there a named editor and a byline on every article?
- Do its articles show up in search for topics you care about?
- Will the article stay findable? Look at pieces that are a couple of years old and see if they are still live.
- Does it link out to the companies it writes about?
- Do AI assistants cite it? Ask one a question from your field and look at the sources.
- Does it fit the market you are entering? A regional or trade outlet can beat a global brand here.
- Would you be comfortable sending the link to a prospect or an investor? If you hesitate, that tells you something.
If an outlet passes most of these, it is probably worth a pitch. If it fails the first two or three, no logo will fix it.
One more thing to keep in mind. Whatever the outlet, an editor decides what runs, and nobody can promise coverage. Anyone who says otherwise is selling something. What you can do is choose outlets carefully, pitch a topic that fits their readers and make sure you have a plan if a placement does not happen.
How we choose outlets with clients
At Edamame PR & Strategy we place founders, executives and companies in publications such as Forbes, Entrepreneur, Financial Times, Inc., VentureBeat, Investing.com, Yahoo! Finance, Business Insider, International Business Times, CIO, Benzinga, HackerNoon and Psychology Today. You can see the full range on our publications page.
We pick outlets with the client, using the questions above. We start from who needs to read the article and what it should do for the company, and only then talk about names. Sometimes the right answer is a well-known business brand. Sometimes it is a trade site that a few thousand buyers read closely.
Our writers have newsroom experience. You approve the topic and review the draft before anything goes out. Each placement is priced and paid for upfront, with no retainer, and it is due within 21 to 60 days of topic approval. If a placement is not delivered, you get a 100% refund. Because editors make the final call, the refund is the promise we make, and not coverage itself. The details are in how it works.
If you are weighing up outlets for your own company, or you have been offered a placement and want a second opinion, ask us. We are happy to look at it with you.