Do you need a PR agency if you already have an in-house team?

Photo by RonaldCandonga on Pixabay
If your company already has its own PR people, you probably don’t need an agency for the everyday work. You may need one for the few placements your team can’t reach, because nobody on staff knows the editors at those publications.
That is a narrower question than “agency or no agency.” It is also more useful. Most founders who ask it aren’t unhappy with their team. They have a short list of publications they want and no clear way to get there.
Do growth-stage companies with in-house PR teams still hire agencies?
Many of the companies we work with at Series B and up already have their own PR teams. They don’t come to us to replace that team. They use us for hard-to-get placements, the ones their team doesn’t have relationships for.
That split makes sense once you look at what each side is set up to do. An in-house team runs launches, writes press releases, briefs executives and keeps the trade press informed. It knows the product, the numbers, the people and the history. An agency brings writers with newsroom experience and relationships at publications the team hasn’t worked with. The team doesn’t have to build those from scratch for one or two stories.
What does an in-house PR team do better than an agency?
Be clear about this before you hire anyone. An outside firm can’t match your team on several things, and paying one to try is a waste.
- Speed on your own news. Your team can get a quote approved the same day. An agency has to ask.
- Context. They know which product claims legal has cleared, which customers can be named and which topics the CEO won’t talk about.
- Relationships with your beat reporters. The reporter who covers your category every week should hear from your own people.
- Fixing problems. If a story gets something wrong, your team should handle the correction. We wrote about what to do when an article gets your company facts wrong. The company’s own people should usually own sensitive conversations like that one.
If most of your PR goals fit inside that list, put the money into the team.
Where do in-house PR teams usually have gaps?
Even strong in-house teams have gaps. That isn’t a failing. Their relationships grow from the coverage the company already gets, so they tend to be deep in trade and tech press and thin elsewhere.
A few patterns we see often:
- New audiences. A company that has always been covered by tech press now wants to reach CFOs, investors or a consumer audience. The publications those readers trust are new ground for the team.
- Executive profiles. Getting the CEO or CFO a byline or a feature in a top business title is a different kind of work from announcing a product. It needs a strong topic idea and writing that meets that editor’s standards.
- Crowded inboxes. There are about 8.4 PR specialists and managers for every journalist in the US. A cold pitch from a team the editor has never heard of competes with all of them.
- Capacity. A team of two that is busy with a launch can’t spend weeks working on one hard placement at the same time.
When the gap is a specific publication, rather than general awareness, outside help makes the most sense.
How do you work with a PR agency without undercutting your in-house team?
Most of the friction between agencies and in-house teams comes from a vague brief. You avoid it by setting the rules early.
- Name the target publications. Give the agency a short list your team has not cracked. Keep the outlets your team already works with off that list.
- Let your team own approvals. Your PR lead should approve topics and review drafts before anything goes to an editor. That keeps the voice consistent and protects the relationships they have built.
- Pick one point of contact. If the agency is talking to the CEO, the CMO and the comms lead at the same time, you will get mixed messages.
- Share what is coming. If a funding announcement or launch is coming up, tell the agency so a placement doesn’t land in the same week and get buried.
- Agree what the agency will deliver. “Better visibility” can’t be measured. “A placement in this publication” can.
That last point is also why the pricing model matters. A monthly retainer pays for activity. For a company with its own team that only needs a few specific placements, paying per placement is usually a cleaner fit. We compare both in retainer vs. pay-per-placement PR. When we spoke to Forbes, we said that clients cared about results, not how hard we worked or how good our process was.
What questions should you ask before hiring a PR agency?
When you talk to agencies, ask questions your in-house team would ask:
- Which of our target publications have you placed articles in, and what kind of articles?
- Who writes the piece, and do they have newsroom experience?
- What happens if the placement doesn’t run?
- How long, roughly, from an approved topic to publication?
- How will you work with our PR lead, not around them?
Vague answers to the first and third questions tell you a lot. Our guide on how to choose a PR agency or publicist goes through more of these checks.
Signs you don’t need outside help yet
Sometimes the honest answer is to wait. You probably don’t need an agency if:
- Your team is getting the coverage you want, and the gaps are about volume rather than access.
- You can’t name the publications you are missing. An agency can’t fix a goal you haven’t defined.
- You have no news, data or executive point of view worth an article yet. Fix that first, and any outside help will go much further.
FAQ
Will an agency step on my in-house team’s relationships?
It shouldn’t, if you set clear limits. Keep the publications your team already works with off the agency’s list, and have your PR lead approve every topic and draft. The agency should add new relationships and leave the existing ones with your team.
Should the agency or my team write the article?
Either can work, but the agency’s writers usually know what a specific editor expects. A common split is that the agency writes and your team checks facts, tone and approvals. Your team stays in control without losing weeks to drafting.
What should my team have ready before briefing an agency?
Bring the short list of publications you want and the executive who will be the face of the piece. Add two or three topic ideas, plus any data or results you are cleared to share. Say who approves topics and drafts on your side, so nothing waits on the wrong person.
If your team has a short list of publications it hasn’t been able to reach, that is the work we do at Edamame PR & Strategy. Clients pay a fixed price per placement upfront. Once you approve the topic, our writers with newsroom experience write the article and you review the draft. Each placement is published within 21 to 60 days of topic approval, and you get a full refund if a placement is not delivered. Tell us which publications you have in mind and we will send you prices.